David Clarke, the tireless Sheffield Hallam University professor whose
decade-long quest in getting his countrys National Archives to release UFO
files compiled by the British Ministry of Defence, reached the end of the road
on June 23 with a final data-dump into the public domain. And he signed off on
that last batch with I-told-you-so relish. There were no smoking guns amid the
52,000 pages released since the incremental undertaking began in 2009, and even
veteran British researcher Jenny Randles lauded Clarkes persistence.
To much fanfare, the British Ministry of Defence finally ended the public
distribution of its largely banal and pedestrian UFO case files last
month/CREDIT: superscholar.org
I may not agree with everything that he says on the subject but I do with
much of it and respect all of his views about the remainder, she wrote in an
addendum to Clarkes parting shots. I certainly know that he is nobodys
puppet. And I, for one, say thank you for his efforts.
Based solely on the evidence presented by UK authorities and the MoDs
ostensible exculpatory transparency Clarkes obituary on that nations ufology
would appear well sourced. But by pulling in some American Skeptical Inquirer
types to fortify his position, Clarke clearly overreaches in his alacrity to
settle the worldwide UFO problem once and for all. No room, of course, for the testimony of former Belgian Air
Force general Wilfried de Brouwer concerning the F-16 scrambles during 1989-90
European wave, or flight-safety issues raised by
former NASA scientist Richard Haines, both of whom presented their evidence
at a symposium just last weekend in Greensboro, N.C. Truth is, you could spend
all night listing Clarke's points of omission and it wouldnt make a dime's
worth of difference here. Not when you forsake good data and credible witnesses
for shopworn cliches, as Clarke chose to.
... My favourite quote of the whole two day media event, he wrote of the
reception to the final MoD document delivery, came from the New York Times as
follows: Dr. Clarke, who has approached the UFO phenomenon from a sociological
perspective, noted that many UFO sightings came from the Scottish city of
Glasgow between 10 p.m. and midnight around the time the pubs are
closing.
Wow. Drunk eyewitnesses again. Fascinating. Zzzz.
Clarke also took a few shots at fellow British ufologists Nick Pope and
Timothy Good for holding preconceived beliefs in their failure to trust The
Official Story because it is in their interest [as UFO authors] to keep the
mystery alive and kicking.
Clarke draws a particularly critical bead on Pope, who anchored the MoDs UFO
desk from 1991-94. He charges Pope with hypocrisy for requesting that his own
UFO-related records remain exempt from disclosure.
The reason these papers are being with-held, Clarke alleges, is because
they contain information about Nick Popes conversion to UFO believer that
followed his alien abduction experience in Florida in 1991. This happened
shortly before he joined the UFO desk when he claims he had little or no
interest in the subject.
Now thats actually interesting.
In denying the abduction story in an email to De Void I've never even seen
a UFO! Pope sought to clarify the record. To wit:
Some UK-based ufologists took exception to the fact that I used some
pseudonymous cases in my book on alien abductions, The Uninvited. I replied
that witness confidentiality applied without exception and added even if it was
me as a joke. The joke spread and I replied that I could "neither confirm nor
deny" (NCND) the rumor. NCND is a Ministry of Defense in-joke, just as I could
tell you but then I'd have to kill you is an in-joke in the intelligence
community.
The only documents that I requested the MoD withhold are ones relating to my
work as a freelance journalist, broadcaster and PR consultant. Clarke is one of
a small group of UK ufologists who are absolutely obsessed with me, in view of
my government work on UFOs. This bizarre groups of oddballs which includes a
deeply unpleasant individual who runs an anti-Semitic blog have submitted
multiple FOI requests to MoD about me and poison the blogosphere with incessant
hate-filled rantings about my government work in many people's eyes I still
work for the government and am personally responsible for the UFO cover-up! I
took the view and the MoD agreed that documents relating to my business
activities were private and should certainly not be passed to some of the more
unpleasant characters who lurk on the fringes of ufology.
Hypocrisy? Well, at the very least, it tells us the MoD still has stuff
tucked away in its UFO files. Pope also reminded De Void as indeed, Clarke
reminded his readers that Clarke never possessed a security clearance during
his UFO research and has reviewed only declassified, or unclassified,
material.
I suspect there's some sour grapes here, Pope went on, because one of the
documents in MoD's UFO files referred to Clarke and a couple of his fellow
ufologists as the UFO spotters - a pejorative UK term meaning someone with an
obsessive, nerdish and naïve perspective on the subject. It was one of my
successors who wrote that, but as I'm the 'public face' of MoD's UFO project,
ufologists tend to blame me for just about everything!
Then theres this caveat from prolific British researcher and author Good,
who greeted the MODs glasnost with a shrug: That was done in a civilian desk
within the MoD which Nick headed ... The real work is done behind the scenes
(e.g. military intelligence). You may recall that in Above Top Secret I
exposed for the first time the Top Secret UFO research unit then at RAF Rudloe
Manor (now elsewhere).
This is running long for a little blog, so lets wrap it up on a word from
Jenny Randles, who discovered something from these MoD crumbs that we Yanks
regrettably picked up on from the Pentagon decades ago, after it was far too
late: ... The MoD was never and is not now the correct body to collate such
data and spend precious resources on a subject that really needs to be
demystified and placed into the realms of scientific study.
OK, so who wants to pony up and start from scratch?
Be Sociable, Share!