Faster Than the Speed of Light?
Harold G. White, a NASA physicist, is working on the concept of warp drive, like on "Star Trek." Some of the original series' ideas fit into the new warp field theories, like the round shape of the engines in the rendering.
Harold G. White, a physicist and advanced propulsion engineer at NASA, beckoned toward a table full of equipment there on a recent afternoon: a laser, a camera, some small mirrors, a ring made of ceramic capacitors and a few other objects.
He and other NASA engineers have been designing and redesigning these instruments, with the goal of using them to slightly warp the trajectory of a photon, changing the distance it travels in a certain area, and then observing the change with a device called an interferometer. So sensitive is their measuring equipment that it was picking up myriad earthly vibrations, including people walking nearby. So they recently moved into this lab, which floats atop a system of underground pneumatic piers, freeing it from seismic disturbances.
The team is trying to determine whether faster-than-light travel warp drive might someday be possible.
Warp drive. Like on Star Trek.
Space has been expanding since the Big Bang 13.7 billion years ago, said Dr. White, 43, who runs the research project. And we know that when you look at some of the cosmology models, there were early periods of the universe where there was explosive inflation, where two points wouldve went receding away from each other at very rapid speeds.
Nature can do it, he said. So the question is, can we do it?
Einstein famously postulated that, as Dr. White put it, thou shalt not exceed the speed of light, essentially setting a galactic speed limit. But in 1994, a Mexican physicist, Miguel Alcubierre, theorized that faster-than-light speeds were possible in a way that did not contradict Einstein, though Dr. Alcubierre did not suggest anyone could actually construct the engine that could accomplish that.
His theory involved harnessing the expansion and contraction of space itself. Under Dr. Alcubierres hypothesis, a ship still couldnt exceed light speed in a local region of space. But a theoretical propulsion system he sketched out manipulated space-time by generating a so-called warp bubble that would expand space on one side of a spacecraft and contract it on another.
In this way, the spaceship will be pushed away from the Earth and pulled towards a distant star by space-time itself, Dr. Alcubierre wrote. Dr. White has likened it to stepping onto a moving walkway at an airport.
But Dr. Alcubierres paper was purely theoretical, and suggested insurmountable hurdles. Among other things, it depended on large amounts of a little understood or observed type of exotic matter that violates typical physical laws.
Dr. White believes that advances he and others have made render warp speed less implausible. Among other things, he has redesigned the theoretical warp-traveling spacecraft and in particular a ring around it that is key to its propulsion system in a way that he believes will greatly reduce the energy requirements.
He is quick to offer up his own caveats, however, saying his warp research is akin to a university science project that is just trying to prove that a microscopic warp bubble can be detected in a lab. Were not bolting this to a spacecraft, he said of the warp technology.
Dr. White was an engineer with a background in the aerospace industry when he came to NASA in 2000, starting his career at the agency by operating the arms of space shuttles. He got his doctorate in physics from Rice University in 2008, and now works on a range of projects aimed at taking NASA beyond the fiery rockets that have long characterized space travel.
For NASA, Dr. Whites warp speed experiments represent a rounding error in its budget, with about $50,000 spent on equipment in an agency that spends nearly $18 billion annually. The agency is far more focused on more achievable projects building the next generation Orion series spacecraft, working on the International Space Station and preparing for a planned future mission to capture an asteroid.
But it has made internal resources available for the project and freed up other engineers to assist Dr. White. It has also restored the pneumatic system in the laboratory Dr. White is using, to allow it to float. The lab was once used to test equipment for Apollo missions and has control panels underneath it that look like they belong in a fallout shelter that time forgot.
Steve Stich, the deputy director of engineering at the Johnson Space Center, said, You always have to be looking towards the future. He held up his iPhone.
Forty years ago, this was Star Trek, Captain Kirk talking on a communicator whenever he wanted to, he said. But today it exists because people made the battery technology that allows this device to exist, worked on the software technology, worked on the computational technology, the touch screen..
Michael Stravato for The New York Times
Dr. Harold White at Johnson Space Center, in Houston, Texas, with a low thrust torsion pendulum.
Theoretically, a warp drive could cut the travel time between stars from tens of thousands of years to weeks or months. But we should probably not book reservations anytime soon.
My personal opinion is that the idea is crazy for now, said Edwin F. Taylor, a former editor of The American Journal of Physics and senior research scientist at M.I.T. Check with me in a hundred years.
But Richard Obousy, a physicist who is president of Icarus Interstellar, a nonprofit group composed of volunteers collaborating on starship design, said it is not airy-fairy, pie in the sky.
We tend to overestimate what we can do on short time scales, but I think we massively underestimate what we can do on longer time scales, he said of the work of Dr. White, who is a friend and Icarus collaborator.
Dr. White likened his experiments to the early stages of the Manhattan Project, which were aimed at creating a very small nuclear reaction merely as proof that it could be done.
They tried to go through and demonstrate a nuclear reactor and generate half a watt, he said. Thats not something youre going to market. Nobodys going to buy that. Its just making sure they understood the physics and science.
Neil deGrasse Tyson, the well-known astrophysicist at the American Museum of Natural History, said some leap beyond our current technology would be needed to make interstellar travel feasible.
Routine travel among the stars is impossible without new discoveries regarding the fabric of space and time, or capability to manipulate it for our needs, he said, adding, By my read, the idea of a functioning warp drive remains far-fetched, but the real take-away is that people are thinking about it reminding us all that the urge to explore continues to run deep in our species.
Still, one of the most dubious is Dr. Alcubierre himself. He listed a number of concerns, starting with the vast amounts of exotic matter that would be needed.
The warp drive on this ground alone is impossible, he said.
And he posed a more fundamental question: How would you turn it on?
At speeds larger than the speed of light, the front of the warp bubble cannot be reached by any signal from within the ship, he said. This does not just mean we cant turn it off; it is much worse. It means we cant even turn it on in the first place.
Dr. White, who has never spoken to Dr. Alcubierre, said I appreciate his thoughts. I dont know whether I agree with all of his observations, based on some work Ive done.
He and I could certainly debate for a very long time, he added.
